Lenny's Pizza Reviews, Ratings & Menu | 8 Reading Rd 103, Flemington

General Info

Nestled in the heart of Flemington, New Jersey, Lenny's Pizza at 8 Reading Rd #103 is a local gem that makes every pizza lover feel right at home. From the moment you step inside, the warm, inviting atmosphere sets the stage for a truly satisfying dining experience. The restaurant’s menu is refreshingly straightforward, focusing on the classics done exceptionally well, which makes it easy to find something that hits the spot every time.

The standout here is undoubtedly the Pepperoni Pizza. Each slice is a perfect balance of savory pepperoni, gooey melted cheese, and a golden, crisp crust that holds up beautifully without being overly heavy. For those who prefer something simpler, the Cheese Pizza is a must-try. Its rich, creamy cheese and subtly seasoned tomato sauce make it a comforting choice that appeals to both kids and adults alike. The freshness of the ingredients really shines through, making each bite feel homemade and satisfying.

Lenny's Pizza isn’t just about the food; the restaurant experience is equally welcoming. With wheelchair accessible seating, it’s clear that they prioritize comfort for every guest. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick takeout or sitting down for a casual dinner, the service is friendly and attentive, creating a relaxed vibe that makes the restaurant feel like a neighborhood favorite. Small plates are also available, perfect for sharing while enjoying a few slices with friends or family.

The location makes it incredibly convenient for both locals and visitors exploring Flemington. Grab a slice and enjoy it at one of their cozy tables, or take advantage of their efficient takeout service if you’re on the go. Free Wi-Fi adds another layer of comfort, whether you’re catching up on emails or simply scrolling while enjoying your meal.

Regulars often rave about the consistency and quality, and the restaurant’s menu ensures there’s something for everyone. From the first bite to the last, Lenny's Pizza offers a genuine, unpretentious pizza experience that keeps guests coming back. The combination of classic flavors, attentive service, and an inviting setting makes this location a standout among pizza spots in the area.

What customers say?

“ Not the best pizza in the area but they have a wide selection and the food has been consistently good. Their delivery is also pretty quick usually and the drivers have been friendly. They make a good pepperoni stromboli as well. ”

- Steve Kraatz -

“ I'm a gnocchi freak and very rarely find them homemade and delicious. Lenny's are clearly fresh and made to order with whatever sauce and toppings I desire. The pizza, wings and cheesesteaks are always delicious. Plus they are always friendly and delivery is fast. ”

- Alisa Silva -

“ When i tell you that this place has the best Cheese steaks in hunterdon im not lying. Being from bucks coutny right outside philly its hard to find the best. This place does cheese steaks for real. ”

- Jason Rose -

“ We order here often. The pizza is good but is out second choice in town. The other place just takes forever to deliver and with three kids we can’t wait over an hour for deliver. Lenny’s sometimes says 45 min but they’re faster most days. Ask for the pie to be well done, it makes a difference I promise. ”

- Katie Perry -

“ Love, love, love the food here. I'm a pizza snob and I haven't found a better pizza in the area. It doesn't stop there, though. The sandwiches are fabulous, namely the Buffalo chicken wrap and the appetizers have been great as well. ”

- Tracy Reasoner -

“ I heard from a local guy to try Lenny’s Pizza. I was a bit confused about where it was as it was in a small shopping center. So I decided today to give Lenny’s a look and a taste . The slices are a nice size and there was a vast array of different toppings not all were too visible from the counter but I tried to take some photos to help you see more. I tried the Sicilian sausage and pepperoni slice .. I found it slightly salty but I’m sensitive to that , and the crust was firm as I like it . I learned there are two versions of a sausage slice.. one has a sweeter sauce and some other differences than the regular one I think he said it was an old fashioned sausage slice.. that would be a next choice for me and their Margarita slice looks appetizing too.. While the interior is small, there’s a few little outside booths to eat at too. Most of the business seemed to be take out .. Go n see what you think! I’d go back and try more myself! ”

- Robert From NY -

“ I stopped into Lenny's for a quick bite before heading back to the office. I decided to go with a slice of plain and a penne vodka slice. The plain slice had a bit of flop and a slightly gummy interior. The cheese and sauce were decent and the crust was pleasantly crispy. The penne vodka slice had a much better structure. It featured a creamy, cheesy sauce with a toasty, smoky crust. The pasta was excellent and filling. All in all, Lenny's puts out a decent pizza. ”

- Cody Obropta -

“ Stopped on a whim driving through and were very pleasantly surprised with how good the pizza was. We got three different types: plain, grandma style, and white with broccoli. All were really tasty and I loved that they served them super hot. I’d definitely stop back again if in the area! ”

- RJ Doidge -

Welcome to Lenny's Pizza

General Info

Lenny's Pizza menu

Lenny's Pizza Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places